AI isn't taking marketing jobs. But it is taking the blame.
Late last year, Harvard Business Review surveyed just over 1,000 executives. Only 2% had made large headcount cuts because of something AI was actually doing. Yet 60% had cut jobs or slowed hiring with AI somewhere in the justification.
So it isn't AI replacing people so much as the idea of AI. And that idea has found a comfortable home in the CFO's office, where marketing headcount looks like the obvious thing for it to hoover up.
If that conversation hasn't reached your door yet, it will. Three things are worth getting straight before it does.
Know what you'd be losing
A marketing job isn't one thing. It's a bundle of tasks, and AI can do some of them well, some badly and some not at all. Cut the role and you lose the whole bundle. When outplacement firm Careerminds surveyed 600 HR leaders who'd made AI-driven cuts, one in three said critical skills had walked out the door with the people. Which rather suggests nobody properly understood what those roles did in the first place.
Know what you could gain
"How can AI cut our headcount?" is the wrong first question for marketing. We exist to add revenue, not remove cost. IKEA shows the other route. When it launched Billie, its customer service chatbot, in 2021, it didn't clear out the call centres. It retrained 8,500 staff as interior design advisers and handlers for the trickier queries. By 2022, Reuters reported that the remote design channel was bringing in €1.3bn a year. That's AI as a propellant.
Know AI's limits
The middle layer always looks like the easy saving. It's also where the judgement and translation happen - the people who turn strategy into something a team can actually get on with on a Monday morning. That work rarely shows up on an org chart, so it's easy to miss until it's gone. Every business needs glue to stop it falling apart and grease to stop it seizing up. AI isn't much good at being either.
Which brings us back to the numbers. In that same Careerminds survey, just 8.4% of HR leaders said their AI-driven restructure had delivered what was promised. That's an awful lot of disappointed people, and you can bet the CFO is among them.
So if you've been slow to reach for the axe, don't panic. Being late to this party is no bad thing. You get to learn from everyone else's hangover.
If you'd like to be ready before the CFO conversation lands, a Waypoint is a good place to start. It's a free, confidential hour with us, and you'll come away with a sharper read on where your team's time and talent really go.
